Friday, May 18, 2012

Bringing Moscow to Allahabad

I wrote this post as a guest on Timothy Hallinan's blog and thought I'd share it here too, since this experience in Allahabad was so amazing:

Arindam Roy—with whom I am writing a novel-in-progress set on two continents—loves concocting surprises. So when I checked into the Hotel Yatrik on a Friday and he told me I’d be giving a talk to students at Allahabad University that Sunday, I managed a grin and a thank you for the opportunity. Then I rushed across the street—risking life and limb amidst the madly rushing rickshaws, wildly over-burdened scooters, and incessantly honking cars—to see if I could get my Mini laptop fixed in time to retrieve my slideshow on my book-research trip to Russia.

On Sunday afternoon, Professor Sanjoy Saksena came to fetch me in a taxi. I was duly grateful, knowing that if I braved the intense humidity and walked the quarter mile to the University, I’d arrive looking more bedraggled than a shipwrecked cat.

The University’s English Department is one of the oldest in India, situated in a grand Edwardian Mughal structure. The Head, Professor Dubey, greeted me warmly, with an offer of tea and many expressions of appreciation. “Your visit will be recorded as was that of Mark Twain, who visited us many years ago,” he said. I was flabbergasted and tried not to show it. Instead I told the students who joined us around the table how remarkable it was that in both Russia and India people could be counted on to treat authors with great respect, regardless of the size of their book sales or reputations. “There is a special appreciation for the act of writing itself that is imbued in both cultures,” I said. I don’t remember if I shared my opinion that this would never happen in celebrity-crazed America.

My presentation, titled The Place of Place in Mystery Writing, always opens with a discussion of how Raymond Chandler, Walter Mosley, and Elizabeth George use the settings of their stories to reveal character—so much so, that in Chandler’s case, Los Angeles became a character in its own right. I then segued into how I got the idea for writing The Last Matryoshka while visiting my mother’s downstairs neighbors, two lovely Russians who held house concerts in their apartment. It was when I reached the slide showing a group of √©migr√© men playing chess on the Brighton Beach boardwalk that it hit me. Here I was, describing a book largely set in Moscow while showing pictures taken in Brooklyn to a group of graduate students in India!

As if to jar me out of my dream, one of the faculty members spoke up. “Do you think that mysteries are really a form of literature?” he asked. Fighting words—more like what I was used to. “Yes, as a matter of fact I do,” I replied. “Just because publishers find it convenient to classify books into genres in order to market them doesn’t mean that some are better than others. It depends on the writer.” I looked around the room and found a young woman I could tell was just dying to raise her hand. I looked directly at her and asked, “What do you think.”  There was an eerie silence…perhaps I had defied some classroom etiquette of which I was unaware. Then she smiled. “I like reading Agatha Christie and I think her books are every bit as good as Charles Dickens,” she said. A girl after my own heart. We were off and running then—even the quiet students leaned forward in their seats to listen.

Afterwards the professor who had challenged me came up to apologize. “Are you kidding?” I asked. “You made it happen.”
Before I left, they draped a beautiful, orange shawl around my shoulders, as is the tradition with honored guests. By that time the classroom was close to inferno temperature and sweltering under the hot wool scarf I did my best not to pass out. Then came the flowers.  I could get used to this.


  1. Interesting post and what a wonderful experience. I love how Agatha Christie has fans all over the world.

    1. Thanks Shirley.. and yes, in both Russia and India I found so many mystery fans!

  2. A nice read, Joyce...i've never been to Allahabad myself, but I got a glimpse of the city from your writing.
    As far as the controversy regarding mystery as a form of literature goes, i think mystery writing forms a very integral part of literature...moreover, writing a piece of mystery is far more difficult as the writer has to concentrate on every triviality of the plot while keeping in mind the intricacies of the literary quality of his/ her work. I'm a voracious reader of Christie thrillers and I feel the effort that the great writer had to put in to fold and unfold her plot through the magic of her words. Writers like Ruskin Bond and Allan Poe have also proved that mystery enjoys its due share in literature. The same goes true for our great Bengali writers like Satyajit Ray and Saradindu Bandhopadhyay. And Tagore himself wrote a few mystery stories which are no less valued amongst his vast literary treasures. So, it very much depends on the author to make his/her mystery a work of literature. I completely go with your view that you voiced at the Allahabad University. So keep writing to gift us with more of your stories :) :)...


  3. Wonderful comments Debasree... I did not know that Tagore wrote mystery stories and will definitely want to check that out! For me the most challenging part of mystery writing is the need to veil the create layers of deception while the poet in me longs to speak truth. I love all kinds of writing, fortunately.
    Thank you so much for you interest in and support of my work.

  4. I don't gett to go anywhere much, so happy to live vicariously through your own travels!

    1. Glad to have you traveling along on my writer's journey, Sandra - reminds me that I need to post more updates! Thanks!

  5. Marvelous work!. Blog is brilliantly written and provides all necessary information I really like this site. Thanks for sharing this useful post.Thanks for the effective information. If you have any requirements for Taxi Services in India then you can book through our website.


 Stay tuned for a virtual trip through La Alpujarra and Ceuta, the places in Spain that inspired me to write Zahara and the Lost Books of Li...